By 1993, Mel Brooks had entered that curious phase of a comedy legend’s career where the instincts are still there, but the execution starts to feel like it’s running on fumes and goodwill. Robin Hood: Men in Tights is unmistakably a later-day Brooks offering, full of familiar gags, recycled rhythms, and the creeping suspicion that the joke arrived on set before the script did. It’s not quite a corpse, but you can hear the wheezing.
Robin of Loxley (Cary Elwes) is captured during the Crusades and imprisoned in Jerusalem, where he befriends the sneezing, heavily accented Asneeze (Isaac Hayes). Together, they stage an escape, freeing fellow prisoners before Robin returns to England, only to find the kingdom under the thumb of Prince John (Richard Lewis). Along the way, he meets Asneeze’s son, Ahchoo (Dave Chappelle), and learns that King Richard is conveniently absent while his brother loots the place like it’s a going-out-of-business sale. Back at Loxley Hall, Robin discovers his family is gone, his estate seized, and his blind servant Blinkin (Mark Blankfield) cheerfully informs him that all hope rests on a mysterious key left behind by his father.
“It says here that the “key” is a lame plot device.”
Robin gathers a crew that feels contractually obligated to be here, including Little John (Eric Allan Kramer) and Will Scarlet O’Hara (Matthew Porretta), to reclaim his land and overthrow Prince John. Along for the ride is Rabbi Tuckman (Mel Brooks), who provides both spiritual guidance and cut-rate circumcisions, proving that no gag is too low if it gets a reaction. Robin also catches the attention of Maid Marian (Amy Yasbeck), who is less interested in romance than in finding someone capable of unlocking her aggressively committed chastity belt.
“Maybe I can get a job as a Disney Princess?”
As Robin trains his Merry Men, the Sheriff of Rottingham (Roger Rees) hires Don Giovanni (Dom DeLuise) to eliminate him during a conveniently staged archery tournament. Marian, accompanied by her towering lady-in-waiting Broomhilde (Megan Cavanagh), sneaks out to warn Robin, setting up a sequence of gags that alternate between clever and aggressively desperate. At the tournament, Robin loses thanks to a split arrow, only to consult the script mid-scene and discover he gets another shot, because continuity is for cowards. This leads to your standard collection of slapstick jokes, ones that were old and tired back in the 1930s.
“Sheriff, at what point does the humour kick in?”
The climax piles on the chaos: assassination attempts, script-breaking jokes, and a conveniently branded “PATRIOT arrow” lead to Robin’s arrest and Marian agreeing to marry the Sheriff to save him. Robin crashes the wedding, duels the Sheriff, accidentally kills him after sparing him, and watches as Latrine (Tracey Ullman) revives the man with a literal Life Saver candy. King Richard (Patrick Stewart) returns just in time to wrap things up, Prince John is hauled off, and Robin and Marian finally marry. Naturally, the chastity belt still won’t open, because the movie refuses to end without one last joke hammering you over the head.
“I’m sorry that I couldn’t write you a funnier movie.”
Stray Observations:
• This wasn’t Brooks’ first shot at Sherwood Forest. He already took a swing with When Things Were Rotten, which vanished faster than dignity at a pie-throwing contest.
• The opening rap sequence is Brooks attempting to stay culturally relevant, which ages about as gracefully as milk left on a radiator.
• Cary Elwes basically built The Princess Bride on channelling Errol Flynn in The Adventures of Robin Hood. Then that same performance got him hired by Mel Brooks. Career planning or cosmic joke, take your pick.
• The maître d ‘ at the Jerusalem prison feels more like a character from a Monty Python sketch rather than from a Mel Brooks movie.
• Mel Brooks appears on screen as Rabbi Tuckman, continuing his long-standing tradition of inserting himself into his own chaos.
• Patrick Stewart shows up as King Richard doing a thick Scottish accent, which is a wink at Sean Connery in Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves. Because nothing says historical accuracy like accents playing musical chairs.
• Maid Marian’s chastity belt drives the plot, despite the tiny detail that those didn’t show up until centuries later.
Historical accuracy quietly packed up and left the building.
When you stack this against Brooks’ earlier work, the cracks become impossible to ignore. Blazing Saddles and Young Frankenstein weren’t just silly, they were tightly constructed machines, firing jokes with ruthless efficiency. Men in Tights, on the other hand, feels like a sketch stretched to feature length, padded with bits that might have killed in a writers’ room but die slowly on screen. The accusations that Brooks is undisciplined, scatological, and prone to groan-worthy humour were always true, but here they’re no longer balanced by precision. It’s chaos without control, which is just… noise.
“If only I could find the ingredients for a good comedy.”
Strip away the tights and you can see the skeleton of Blazing Saddles underneath, awkwardly transplanted into medieval England. The outsider hero, the corrupt ruler, the meta-humour, the anachronistic jokes. It’s all here, just diluted and oddly tired. Instead of skewering a genre with sharp insight, the film mostly settles for poking at Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves, which is such an easy target it barely qualifies as satire. Low-hanging fruit is still fruit, but you don’t build a meal around it. That the overall look of the production is cheap doesn’t help things much either.
This film breaks the fourth wall but not the budget.
And then there’s the problem of time. Brooks’ best films feel oddly timeless, their jokes landing across decades because they’re rooted in character and structure. Men in Tights is aggressively, painfully 1990s. The rap intro, the pop-culture references, and the general sense that the film is chasing relevance instead of defining it. Watching it now feels less like revisiting a classic and more like opening a time capsule filled with mildly embarrassing choices. Nothing says current more than seeing guys in tights badly rapping.
Boys in the Robin Hood.
As a Robin Hood adaptation, it lands somewhere in the middle of the pack, which is both generous and a little depressing. It borrows heavily from Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves while nodding to The Adventures of Robin Hood and the enduring shadow of Errol Flynn. Cary Elwes occasionally looks like Flynn’s long-lost twin, and for brief moments, the film almost convinces you it could recapture that swashbuckling magic. Then it remembers it’s a parody and promptly undercuts itself with jokes that treat everyone like they’ve misplaced their brain, which is a problem, because this kind of comedy only really works when at least one person in the room isn’t a complete bloody idiot.
Daffy Duck’s Robin Hood had more wit than this.
The cast is, frustratingly, the closest thing the film has to a saving grace. Cary Elwes carries the movie with a straight-faced charm that suggests he’s in a much better film happening somewhere just out of frame. Roger Rees chews the scenery with admirable commitment, while Amy Yasbeck gamely plays along with material that rarely deserves her. Even Dave Chappelle shows early flashes of the sharp comedic voice he’d later refine, though here he’s mostly stuck reacting to jokes that feel a draft or two away from working.
“Trust me, my stand-up specials will slay ’em all.”
In conclusion, Robin Hood: Men in Tights isn’t a full-blown disaster. It clears the very low bar set by the parody films of Jason Friedberg and Aaron Seltzer, which is like bragging you outran a parked car. The real frustration is that it’s just competent enough to remind you what Mel Brooks used to do effortlessly, yet sloppy enough to make you wish he’d either sharpened the script or embraced total chaos. There are laughs in here, scattered like loose change, but they’re buried under dated references and shapeless storytelling that keep the film grounded. Maybe time will be kinder, but for now, it lingers in Brooks’ filmography like an awkward middle child, rummaging through its older siblings’ wardrobes and never quite pulling anything off.
Robin Hood: Men in Tights (1993)
Overall
-
Movie Rank - 5.5/10
5.5/10
Summary
With Robin Hood: Men in Tights, Mel Brooks gives us a sporadically funny but largely unfocused parody that leans too heavily on easy targets and dated humour. Not the worst Robin Hood tale, but easily one of the lesser entries in Brooks’ once-mighty comedic arsenal.

